OFF THE SHELF


 
IN THIS ISSUE
 Cave of Stars
 The Architects of Emortality


RECENT REVIEWS
 Darwin's Radio
 The Pure Product
 Otherland: Mountain of Black Glass
 Dune: House Atreides
 The Martians
 Gravity
 We
 Year's Best SF 4
 Starfish
 Way of the Pilgrim


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions

Cave of Stars

When two cultures collide, which will survive?

* Cave of Stars
* By George Zebrowski
* HarperPrism
* $24.00/$35.00 Canada
* Hardcover, Sept. 1999
* ISBN 0-06-105299-X

Review by Curt Wohleber

Three centuries after the destruction of Earth, humankind has spread out across the stars. The theocratic government on Tau Ceti IV is dedicated to order and stability. The New Vatican restricts access to knowledge, discourages technical innovation and deals harshly with heretics and dissidents. Only through such discipline, the ruling clerics say, can they avoid another cataclysm like the one that destroyed humanity's homeworld.

Our Pick: A-

From the depths of space, however, come humans who embody an entirely different way of life, which they call "macrolife." They explore the cosmos in hundred-kilometer-long space habitats called mobiles. A cybernetic network called "the Link" connects the millions of inhabitants of each mobile, forming a kind of collective intelligence. Nanotechnology and genetic engineering have endowed the macrolife residents with immortality.

Voss Rhazes pities the Cetians, who endure brief lives of hardship. Josephus Bely, known as Pope Peter III, is old and dying. He fears death despite his professed faith in the afterlife. He begs the visitors to restore his health, but the pope's illegitimate daughter and his chief advisor argue that it would be best to let the pope die naturally, clearing the way for a more progressive government. Voss agrees that this would be best for the people of Tau Ceti.

Neither Voss nor the other macrolifers ever suspect that the aged pope could be a threat. While the pope on Old Earth was said to hold the keys to heaven, Pope Peter holds the keys to hell, and his last act devastates both worlds.

Matters of macrolife and macrodeath

Cave of Stars, a companion volume to Zebrowski's acclaimed 1979 novel Macrolife, is an extremely thoughtful book, in the sense that the characters spend a lot of time thinking. This is not a bad thing, for Zebrowski's vivid characters personalize and enliven time-worn debates about faith and reason, tradition and change, responsibility and individual autonomy. Zebrowski comes down on the side of reason, but the macrolifers pay a terrible price when they underestimate the desperation of those whose faith is challenged.

The novel becomes less cerebral as the story evolves into a tense struggle for survival. Cave of Stars sometimes reads like three novels spliced into a single narrative. The opening chapters are reminiscent of Ursula Le Guin's Hainish novels; an interlude on the macrolife habitat recalls the techno-utopia of Iain Banks' Culture novels (though Zebrowski's Macrolife preceded the Culture series by a decade); and the story finally morphs into a suspenseful space adventure.

The later chapters seem rushed, especially when compared to the careful deliberation at the beginning of the novel, and the macrolifers lack the psychological complexity of the Cetians. But these are minor defects in an otherwise magisterial work of speculative fiction. In Zebrowski's capable hands, the shifts in the story line seem natural, for it is history that Zebrowski is narrating, bloody and chaotic up close, but when viewed from the distance of years it becomes a grand procession toward a future of wonder and menace and infinite possibilities.

Thought-provoking ideas. Stuff blowing up. What more could you ask? -- Curt

Back to the top.


The Architects of Emortality

Brian Stableford's mysterious future continues...

* The Architects of Emortality
* By Brian Stableford
* Tor Books
* $24.95/$34.95 Canada
* Hardcover, Oct. 1999
* ISBN: 0-312-87207-0

Review by Clinton Lawrence

In this sequel to Brian Stableford's novel Inherit the Earth, wealthy industrialist Gabriel King is discovered murdered in his New York apartment. The crime is a particularly unusual one, and the UN police are understandably anxious. The weapon used against King was a genetically engineered flower that consumed his flesh. The police fear it could be the beginning of another biotech war. The only clues are a mysterious young woman who visited King shortly before his death, and another set of flowers with a cryptic quote from Charles Baudelaire's poem "Au Lecteur." There are few people alive with the technical expertise to create such plants, and one of them, a genetic floral artist named after 19th-century writer Oscar Wilde, shows up at the crime scene.

Our Pick: A-

The police immediately suspect Wilde, but he denies culpability, claiming someone summoned him to King's apartment. Since he's there already, the police invite him to provide his technical analysis while also contacting Wilde's rival, Walter Czastka, for a second opinion. Wilde believes there's only one other person with both the skill and artistry to create such a plant, a mysterious recluse who uses the pseudonym Rappaccini. Meanwhile, another guest joins the investigation, Michael Lowenthal, who won't disclose the identity of his employers.

As the police try to track down Rappaccini's true identity and location, Wilde discovers that the flesh-consuming plants are based on a formerly extinct species that Wilde himself brought back into existence. He and Regina Chai, the police forensic scientist, also discover that the plant was engineered specifically to attack King's DNA. The mystery deepens when Michi Urashima is discovered murdered by the same method in San Francisco. The only apparent connection between the two is that both were students at an Australian university nearly two centuries earlier. And while Wilde suspects Rappaccini, Police Sgt. Charlotte Holmes still suspects Wilde, and Lowenthal believes Czastka is behind the murders.

Science is an art

Although science is crucial to The Architects of Emortality, the book is mostly a murder mystery, and quite a good one. And it's not necessary to have read Inherit the Earth to enjoy this novel, although there are references to events in the first book which will make the second one clearer. Both volumes are the beginnings of an ongoing future history saga, and Stableford's choice of creating that future through a series of mysteries is an interesting and unusual approach.

In The Architects of Emortality, the central mystery doesn't connect to the underlying social fabric and controversies related to the technology and business of immortality as strongly as it does in Inherit the Earth. In fact, the social pressures of having mortal and possibly immortal generations living simultaneously are hinted at, but not really explored. That seems to be something of a problem, since presumably this is the central issue of Stableford's future tableau.

What Stableford does well, though, he does very well. Among the more interesting concepts in The Architects of Emortality is his portrayal, through Wilde's and Rappaccini's characters, of science as a fine art. The obvious inspiration and many references to 19th-century literature and literary figures reinforce this idea. Wilde's character, one of flamboyance, pretense, playful arrogance, and wild speculation mixed with insightful deduction, is particularly effective. The mystery itself is well-conceived, though in the end, fairly straightforward. By the second half of the book, it's pretty clear who's behind the murders, but the real motive and reasons for the choice of victims remain elusive.

As a science fiction mystery, The Architects of Emortality is a fine book that will entertain many. As a piece of a future history still under construction, its effectiveness probably can't be fully assessed until more of Stableford's future milieu is published.

As much as I enjoyed this book, and as much as I admire Stableford's attempts to try a different approach to future history, I'm a bit suspicious that his execution in the end might not match his ambition. -- Clint

Back to the top.




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.