CLASSIC SCI-FI


RECENT REVIEWS
 The Man in the High Castle
 THX 1138
 Things to Come
 Ringworld
 Stand on Zanzibar
 Fantastic Planet
 Star Trek: Mission to Horatius
 Journey to the Centre of the Earth
 The Mote in God's Eye
 Outland


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions

Thrilling Science Fiction, Vols. 1 & 2

Pictures worth a thousand worlds

* Thrilling Science Fiction, Vols. 1 & 2
* Edited by Bill Black
* Paragon Publications
* $9.95 Each

Review by Jeff Berkwits

Though traditional SF has never been a particularly profitable part of the comic book industry, over the years publishers have occasionally attracted readers with titles that focused upon either thoughtful speculative scenarios or eccentric space operas. This was especially true during the Golden Age of comics, in the 1940s and 1950s, when for only a dime per issue fans could follow the exploits of numerous heavenly heroes and otherworldly warriors.

Our Pick: B-

Thrilling Science Fiction reprints some of that era's most intriguing illustrated adventures. The first two volumes of this ongoing series present tales culled primarily from the long-running Planet Comics, which showcased stories starring characters like Mysta of the Moon, Gale Allen and the Girl Squadron, Auro - Lord of Jupiter and Mars - God of War. Sundry selections featuring these individuals are included here, along with a few narratives from lesser-known periodicals such as Captain Science and Buster Brown Comics.

Both Thrilling Science Fiction books begin with editorials outlining the origin of each strip and the credentials of the artists. Many of the drawings spotlight early efforts by renowned illustrators like Reed Crandall, Wallace Wood, Joe Orlando and Steve Ditko, although a number of other cartoonists are also represented. All of the internal artwork is printed in black-and-white, and each volume sports a full-cover color.

Long-forgotten wonders

When discussing classic comic books, most experts generally cite titles such as Weird Science, Weird Fantasy and Incredible Science Fiction as benchmarks for illustrated speculative storytelling. While the accolades bestowed upon these famous publications are certainly well deserved, the Thrilling Science Fiction anthologies introduce contemporary comic fans to long-forgotten SF selections that appeared in other, frequently unheard-of periodicals.

The writing on most of the works is generally unsophisticated and formulaic, but the artwork is usually competent and compelling. Readers can clearly observe the dexterity of draftsmen such as Bernie Krigstein, George Evans and Graham Ingels, all of whom either ultimately went on to or simultaneously worked at industry powerhouse EC Comics. It's also interesting to survey the surprisingly abundant tales featuring buxom yet bold women as main characters, who through daring, skill and spectacular sex appeal inevitably manage to defeat evil aliens and interplanetary overlords.

The overall presentation is adequate, though a table of contents and page numbers would have been a welcome addition. It would also have been beneficial had the works been printed in color on higher quality paper. However, both volumes still retain a requisite sense of wonder, ensuring that individuals who choose to investigate these old-fashioned adventures will truly experience Thrilling Science Fiction.

Folks interested in seeing more vintage SF comic art might also want to check out Paragon's Golden-Age Greats, Vol. 12, which is devoted to similar speculative serials including Kenton of the Star Patrol, Solar Legion and Space Mouse. -- Jeff


Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Anime | Sound Space | Site of the Week | Letters


Copyright © 1998-2003, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.